Scotland launches its Third Just Transition Commission – England waits for its First

Oct 5, 2026

Stephen Smellie, UNISON, is one of two trade union members of the third Just Transition Commission to be set up by the Scottish government. The other is Richard Hardy of Prospect. Co-Chaired by Dave Reay formerly of Edinburgh University and Satwat Rehman of One Parent Families Scotland,  it has 15 members from Academia, Business, Unions and NGOs. Set up to advise the Scottish government on what it needs to do it will have to build on the stinging critique made by the outgoing Second Commission.

Our assessment is that progress has fallen short of what is needed. Unless we renew our ambition and redouble our efforts, the enormous opportunity – both for meaningful climate action and for building a fairer and more prosperous country – will be lost.

And follow up on its outgoing recommendations.

  • Progress has fallen short of what is needed. Instead of planning for success, we are reacting to crises.
  • Deliver anticipatory place-based planning for at-risk sites and regions and progress sectoral plans. There is no just path to Net Zero through deindustrialisation.
  • A just transition is still possible but requires courageous action across sectors. To maintain the social license for climate action, the Scottish Government must now use all levers at its disposal.
  • Investment for the just transition must be mobilised through financial leadership and market-shaping interventions. This includes incentive structures, conditionalities and community wealth building measures.
  • Communities and local authorities need capacity and resource to keep pace with developments, shape the transition and influence major decisions affecting their area.
  • Improve delivery with more meticulous monitoring and evaluation, applying data effectively in partnerships at local and regional level.

A similar Just Transition Commission has been set up in Northern Ireland. The work done in consulting, organising, mobilising and advising is invaluable, and we need the same thing in England, and the English regions, and Wales.

Stephen’s article is the first of what we hope will be a series, so the movement in the rest of the UK can learn from the Scottish experience – what to copy – what to avoid – while we push for similar bodies here.

Scottish Just Transition Commission re-launched

The third Scottish Just Transition Commission has now been launched. This follows the commitment given by First Minister John Swinney that a Just Transition remains one of his government’s priorities.

Scotland was the first nation to establish a JTC to advise the government on the necessary steps to take to achieve a Just Transition. Others have followed, such as Northern Ireland, but not England. The JTC brings together representatives from the environment and trade union movements, industry, academia, health, economists and anti-poverty activists who work to a plane related to government planning and their own identified priorities.

The second JTC published its final report ahead of the Scottish Parliamentary election. Its title, No Time to Lose, summed up its message, not enough had been done to deliver on Just Transition. During its term it had reported on the closure of Grangemouth, the continuing loss of jobs in the North Sea, the failure to develop supply chains for the renewable sector and therefore a disappointing record on new jobs, and the continuing failure to deliver the potential community wealth that public or shared ownership of renewables could have meant for communities.

This latest Commission therefore starts from a position critical of past action or inaction.

The Government have proposed that the Commission look at Adaptation and Climate Resilience alongside a range of issues from skills and jobs to how a Just Transition can impact on the Government priorities of health and eradicating child poverty.

As Net-Zero no longer has a political consensus of support and the faith in delivering a Just  Transition amongst many workers is much diminished there is a need to restore public trust that the move to a low carbon economy will be fair, that alternative industries will provide quality work and that communities will benefit through sharing in the profits being made by companies and, mostly, foreign corporations.

That is a job for governments, not the Commission, but they have a part to play in identifying the actions that government ministers and industry must deliver on.

No Time to Lose: Final Report of the 2nd Just Transition Commission (2026) – Just Transition Commission

 

Join the debate

Send us your contribution to the debate. We will contact you about using it here on our News & Debate page.